Creating Public Value
Strategic Management in Government
Introduction
Nova: What if I told you the most important management book of the last thirty years wasn't about Apple, Tesla, or any Silicon Valley unicorn? What if the most radical ideas about leadership, strategy, and value creation came from… the public sector? Today we're diving into Creating Public Value: Strategic Management in Government by Mark H. Moore, a book that has quietly reshaped how governments around the world think about their mission.
Nova: I know, right? We tend to think of public managers as bureaucrats pushing paper, following rules, avoiding risk. Moore says that's exactly the problem. He argues public managers should act more like entrepreneurs. Not chasing profit, but chasing something he calls "public value."
Nova: That's the twist — and it's why this book has been so influential for nearly three decades. Moore is not saying government should adopt private sector practices wholesale. He's building an entirely different framework. He's asking: what does it mean to create value when your bottom line isn't money, but justice, safety, education, environmental protection? And more provocatively: should public managers wait for elected officials to tell them what to do, or should they help define what's valuable?
Nova: He begins by looking at real public managers — people running police departments, library systems, environmental agencies — and noticing something striking. The most effective ones weren't just implementing orders efficiently. They were reshaping what their organizations did, why they did it, and who they did it for. They were, in Moore's language, creating public value. Today we're going to unpack what that means, why it was controversial when the book came out in 1995, and why its ideas are more relevant now than ever.
What Is Public Value?
The Core Idea
Nova: Let's start with the big idea at the heart of the book. Moore opens with a deceptively simple question: what is the public sector equivalent of shareholder value? In the private sector, you have a clear metric. Are you making money for shareholders? But in government, what's the equivalent? There's no stock price for the Environmental Protection Agency. There's no quarterly earnings report for a public library.
Nova: But also terrifying, because how do you know if you're succeeding? Moore's answer is public value. He defines it as the value an organization produces for the collective rather than for individual consumers. It's not just what citizens want — it's what's good for the public as a whole, including future generations and people who don't have a voice.
Nova: Moore acknowledges this is the central challenge. Unlike private value, which markets price through supply and demand, public value has to be defined through political and social processes. There's no automatic feedback loop. Public managers have to actively engage with citizens, elected officials, and stakeholders to figure out what's valuable. And — this is crucial — Moore argues that public managers shouldn't just passively receive that definition. They should help shape it.
Nova: More like by seeing possibilities that citizens and politicians might miss. Moore uses a great example: the director of a public library system. The traditional view says the director's job is to run libraries efficiently — keep the buildings open, manage the book collection, stay within budget. But Moore describes a director who thought bigger. She realized libraries could be community hubs for early childhood literacy, job training programs, immigrant integration. She saw public value beyond just lending books. But she couldn't just impose that vision. She had to build political support, reallocate resources, and prove it was worth doing.
Nova: Exactly. Moore calls this the "restless, value-seeking imagination" of the public manager. And this is where the book gets really interesting — because Moore doesn't just celebrate visionary leadership. He builds a rigorous framework for how to do it responsibly. That framework is what he calls the strategic triangle.
Moore's Signature Framework
The Strategic Triangle
Nova: If you take one thing away from Creating Public Value, it's the strategic triangle. This is Moore's practical tool for thinking about public sector strategy, and it's been adopted by governments from the UK to New Zealand to Singapore.
Nova: First, the public value proposition. What value are you trying to create, and for whom? This is the "why" of your organization. Second, the authorizing environment. Who needs to give you permission and resources? This includes elected officials, courts, interest groups, the media, and the public. Third, operational capacity. Do you actually have the people, skills, systems, and resources to deliver?
Nova: That's the surface similarity, but Moore shows how each element works differently in the public sector. Let's start with the value proposition. A private company can focus on a narrow customer segment — say, luxury car buyers. A public agency can't just serve the people who walk through the door. It has to think about the public at large, including people who can't or won't engage. A police department isn't just serving crime victims. It's serving the entire community's interest in safety and justice, including the rights of the accused.
Nova: Much messier. In business, you ultimately answer to a board and shareholders. In government, you answer to a vast web of overseers — legislators, courts, inspectors general, the media, interest groups, voters. Moore argues that navigating this environment isn't just about compliance. It's about building and sustaining legitimacy. The best public managers actively cultivate their authorizing environment. They don't wait for permission. They build coalitions.
Nova: This is one of Moore's most controversial arguments. He says the idea of neutral competence — that public managers just neutrally implement whatever elected officials decide — is a myth and not even desirable. Politics and administration are inevitably intertwined. The question isn't whether public managers engage in politics, but whether they do so responsibly, transparently, and in pursuit of public value rather than personal gain.
Nova: Public organizations often inherit their capacity — legacy IT systems, civil service rules, union contracts, fixed budgets — in ways that make it much harder to pivot than a private company. But Moore shows through case studies that creative public managers find ways to build new capacity. They form partnerships, redeploy staff, experiment with new technologies. The point is that all three corners of the triangle have to be aligned. A great idea without political support goes nowhere. Political support without operational capacity is empty rhetoric. Operational capacity without a clear value proposition is just busy work.
Public Value Entrepreneurs at Work
Case Studies in Action
Nova: Moore grounds all of this theory in real stories, and that's what makes the book come alive. One of the most memorable case studies involves the Environmental Protection Agency in its early years under Administrator William Ruckelshaus.
Nova: Right. Congress had passed a bunch of ambitious environmental laws — the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act — but the laws were vague about enforcement. Ruckelshaus had to figure out what the EPA's public value proposition actually was. Was it to be a neutral scientific advisor? An aggressive enforcer? A collaborative partner with industry? He chose to position the EPA as a tough but fair enforcer, taking visible actions against major polluters. This wasn't dictated by statute. He created that value proposition.
Nova: Exactly. And to do that, he needed to manage the authorizing environment. Congress was watching. Industry was furious. The public was mobilizing. Ruckelshaus held public hearings, built credibility with the press, and demonstrated to Congress that the agency was doing what the public wanted. At the same time, he had to build operational capacity from scratch — hiring scientists, setting up regional offices, creating enforcement protocols. All three corners of the triangle, built simultaneously.
Nova: Moore also examines a district attorney's office, a youth services agency, and a police department. In each case, he shows a manager who refused to accept the narrow definition of their job. The police commissioner who said: our goal isn't just to make arrests. It's to reduce fear and build community trust. The youth services director who realized that placing troubled kids in institutions was failing them and their communities, so she pivoted to family-based interventions. These aren't stories of rule-breaking. They're stories of managers expanding the conception of what their organizations could accomplish.
Nova: He's honest about the mixed results. Some succeeded brilliantly. Some faced backlash. Some learned hard lessons. The point isn't that every entrepreneurial public manager wins. The point is that the ones who make a difference think and act differently. They don't ask "what am I authorized to do?" They ask "what's worth doing, and how can I make it happen?"
Critiques and Continuing Relevance
The Controversy and the Legacy
Nova: The discomfort is real, and Moore's book sparked serious debate. Critics from the traditional public administration school argued that Moore was giving cover to bureaucratic activism — unelected officials pursuing their own agendas. From the left, some worried that "public value" was just a way to smuggle market logic into government. From the right, others worried it gave government too much creative license.
Nova: He makes a few key arguments. First, he says the traditional model of public administration — where managers just implement orders from above — never really described reality. Public managers always exercise discretion. The question is whether they do it thoughtfully and accountably. Second, he argues that in a complex world, we need entrepreneurial public managers because elected officials can't anticipate every situation. The legislature writes broad laws. Someone has to translate them into action. That translation inevitably involves judgment.
Nova: Not at all. The strategic triangle is precisely a framework for accountability. You have to show that your value proposition has merit, that you have authorization, and that you can deliver. Moore also emphasizes that public managers must engage in continuous public deliberation — explaining their choices, listening to feedback, adjusting when they're wrong. It's entrepreneurial but it's not authoritarian.
Nova: Remarkably well. In the late 1990s and 2000s, the UK government under Tony Blair adopted "public value" as a guiding concept for public sector reform. The BBC used it to justify its public funding model. New Zealand, Australia, and several European countries incorporated the framework into how they train senior civil servants. Harvard's Kennedy School built entire executive programs around it. Moore himself published a follow-up in 2013 called Recognizing Public Value, which explored how to measure and account for public value creation.
Nova: The questions Moore raised are more urgent than ever. We're grappling with existential challenges — climate change, pandemics, inequality, AI governance — that require exactly the kind of entrepreneurial public leadership Moore described. Governments can't just administer the status quo. They have to imagine and create new forms of public value. At the same time, trust in government is fragile. The balancing act Moore described — being both innovative and accountable, both visionary and humble — is the central challenge of public leadership today.
Conclusion
Nova: So where does all this leave us? Creating Public Value is, at its core, an argument for taking public management seriously as a creative, strategic endeavor. Moore refuses the lazy division where politicians set goals and bureaucrats just execute. He argues that public managers are — and should be — active participants in defining what's valuable for society.
Nova: If listeners take one idea away, let it be this: the next time you encounter a public service that works well — a library that transforms a community, a park that brings a city together, a regulatory agency that protects without stifling — ask yourself: who made that happen? Chances are there was a public manager somewhere who didn't just follow the rules, but imagined something better and fought to make it real. That's public value creation.
Nova: Beautifully put. Mark H. Moore's Creating Public Value remains essential reading for anyone who believes government can — and must — do more than just keep the lights on. It's a book about leadership, strategy, and the quiet heroism of public servants who dare to ask: what is truly worth doing?